I cannot wait until the next “Reacher” thriller comes out. It will top the New York Times bestseller list for sure. I actually met Lee Childs, the author of the series, at a book signing at the sorely missed Barnes and Noble store near Lincoln Center, and he seemed a very personable man who signed my book with graciousness and a smile. I have read every one of his books. They are great! One problem is that I cannot remember which is which. Give me the title, and I cannot recall the story. In fact, I really cannot remember any of the stories except that, in the end, Reacher wins and his adversaries lose. Fun to read, predictable endings!
On the other hand, I can quote “Alice in Wonderland” with ease. Well, that may be unfair because it is my favorite book, but I can also remember the story line of many of the books I read as a child – the really good books, that is. That list includes books like “Winnie the Pooh,” “Charlotte’s Web,” “Wind in the Willows,” “The Tale of Peter Rabbit,” “The Little Prince,” “Gulliver’s Travels,” “20,000 Leagues under the Sea,” “The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe” and quite a few more. I remember them vividly because they created treasured memories.
I am still a compulsive reader. I cannot count all the titles that I have downloaded onto my iPad from the Amazon Kindle App. Some are serious non-fiction works, but most are best sellers like those of Mr. Childs. Enormously enjoyable to read but, within a week, virtually forgotten as to actual story line!
So what happened? Why this loss of memory of the crime thriller plots while recall of books I read so long ago? I think I have to admit that many great children’s books have been made into movies and referred to by other authors, so repetition must cement one’s memories. Classic children’s books become part of our cultural landscape so seamlessly that we hardly notice their existence when they resurface again and again in different ways. Certainly, when I read “Robinson Crusoe,” I had not read as many books as I have now. But I think that what made such books great was that I could not anticipate how they ended. When Charlotte the spider died, I was genuinely upset. I had not seen that coming when I was age eight. (Sorry if I should have given you a “spoiler alert”!) There is no formula to the “Alice” Books; Lewis Carroll (or, if you prefer real names, Charles Dodgson) thought “outside of the box” before the phrase was invented.
I remember that in an interview with “Game of Thrones” author George R.R. Martin, he said that he regularly tried to surprise his audience. If Tom Cruise appears at the beginning of a movie, he said, you can bet that Tom Cruise is not going to be killed off. He is too big a star and there are such things as “sequels”. Charlotte did not have a sequel; she wove her web and died. To George R.R. Martin’s credit, (why the R.R. business?) he does have a tendency to kill off his characters just when you really feel emotionally invested in them.
Movies used to be considered the enemy of books. “Read, don’t watch!” we were told. I am not sure that advice still stands. Many children read the” Harry Potter” books (truly wonderful as they are) after seeing the movies. The “Hunger Games” books similarly were more widely read after the movie came out. Also, to be fair to Mr. Childs and all his fellow authors, maybe they are not writing their books to be recorded in history as classics. They are making a lot of money doing something they enjoy, and good for them, the libertarian within me says.
Still, in “The Wind in the Willows”, Ratty says, and I quote this from memory – “There is absolutely nothing, half as much worth doing as simply messing about in boats.” As a person who has had the good fortune of being able to “mess about” in boats over the years, I remember that sentiment as if I read it yesterday. I do not think I have read the book in over 50 years.
Who can explain all this? Not I! In the meantime, I cannot wait until the next Reacher book comes out.
Ronald P. Stewart
P.S. Since I wrote this article in early September, “Personal” by Lee Childs (the “Reacher” novel I referred to) has reached the #1 position on the New York Times Best Seller Fiction list.